| Product | Ideal for | Price from | Free version | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lowest monthly base fee | $39 per month plus $4 per participant | No | Visit | |
| Full service on a budget | $80 per month plus $5 per eligible employee | No | Visit | |
| Hands-off investing | $100 per month plus $5 per participant | No | Visit | |
| First-time employer plans | $100 per month plus $500 setup fee | No | Visit | |
| Low-cost index funds | $4,850 per year for up to 15 participants | No | Visit | |
| Owner-only plans at no cost | $0 per month, no setup fee | Yes | Visit | |
| Flat annual fee up to 30 staff | $1,500 per year for up to 30 employees | No | Visit | |
| First-time plans through payroll | $49 per month plus $8 per active participant | No | Visit |

Ideal for: Lowest monthly base fee

Guideline, now part of Gusto, sells a 401k built for small employers that want a clear monthly bill and little admin work. The Starter plan costs $39 per month plus $4 per active participant, and it covers recordkeeping, payroll integration, government filings and live support. Core costs $89 per month plus $8 per participant and adds employer contributions, vesting schedules and a higher contribution limit. Enterprise costs $149 per month with flexible per-participant pricing and priority support.
The platform handles compliance testing, Form 5500 filing and participant support, and it connects with payroll providers such as Gusto, QuickBooks Payroll, ADP and Rippling. Fund fees are low, with average expense ratios near 0.07 percent, and participants pay an asset-based account fee that ranges from 0.15 percent to 0.35 percent depending on the tier. The main limit is the Starter tier, which caps employee contributions at $6,000 and does not allow employer contributions, so growing teams usually need Core.

Ideal for: Full service on a budget

Human Interest offers three 401k tiers with published monthly prices, which makes it easy to budget before you talk to sales. Essentials costs $80 per month plus $5 per eligible employee, Complete costs $180 per month plus $7 per eligible employee, and Concierge costs $280 per month plus $9 per eligible employee. A one-time setup fee of $499 may apply. Employees pay asset-based fees of 0.01 percent per month for advice and 0.05 percent per month for recordkeeping.
The service includes automatic enrollment, payroll sync with more than 600 payroll providers, and model portfolios built by its advisory arm. Complete adds 3(16) fiduciary services, Form 5500 filing, an ERISA fidelity bond and loan approval, while Concierge adds a named account manager, compliance monitoring and audit defense. The entry tier leaves compliance work with you, so read the feature table on the pricing page and confirm which tasks stay on your desk at each tier.

Ideal for: Hands-off investing

Betterment at Work brings the firm's automated investing approach to employer 401k plans. The Essential plan costs $100 per month, billed annually, plus $5 per participant per month, and the Pro plan costs $150 per month plus $7 per participant per month. Both add a 0.25 percent annual advisory fee on participant assets. Flagship is custom priced. A one-time implementation fee of $500 applies to new plans and $1,000 to conversions.
Each plan includes a dedicated onboarding specialist, payroll integrations, compliance testing, a draft Form 5500 and fiduciary support. Pro adds flexible plan design features such as vesting and new comparability, plus matching on student loan payments and financial coaching as an add-on. The 0.25 percent advisory fee is the cost to watch: it is small in year one and grows with plan assets, so model the total cost at your expected balance, not just the monthly base fee.

Ideal for: First-time employer plans
Fidelity Advantage 401(k) is built for businesses with 2 to 1,000 employees that are starting their first 401k. The employer pays $100 per month plus a $500 one-time implementation fee, and Fidelity acts as plan sponsor and as 3(16) and 3(38) fiduciary while filing Form 5500. Participants pay a recordkeeping fee of $25 per quarter and a 0.125 percent investment advisory fee on their balance.
The fund lineup is broad, covering low-cost index funds, actively managed funds and target-date options, and the brand carries deep support resources for plan sponsors. Fidelity also offers a self-employed 401k with no setup or annual account fee for owner-only businesses, which is a separate product from Advantage. The main drawback is that Advantage is for first-time plans only; employers converting an existing plan move to the traditional Fidelity 401k, which is priced per plan, so ask for that quote in writing.

Ideal for: Low-cost index funds
Vanguard Retirement Plan Access, known as VRPA, gives small and midsize employers access to Vanguard recordkeeping and its low-cost fund lineup. The bundled annual fee starts at $4,850 per year for up to 15 participants with under $10 million in assets, plus $75 per year for each participant from 16 to 50. An unbundled option costs $3,775 per year for recordkeeping alone, with a separate third-party administrator handling plan administration.
The investment menu centers on Vanguard Target Retirement Funds and other low-cost Vanguard funds, with about 12,000 non-Vanguard funds also available, and the plan supports firm-specific 3(21) and 3(38) arrangements and model portfolios. The drawback is transparency: plan installation and setup fees are charged separately and the amounts are not published, and direct recordkeeping and the pooled employer plan are quoted per plan. Get the full fee schedule, including setup and transaction fees, before you compare VRPA with a flat monthly provider.

Ideal for: Owner-only plans at no cost
Charles Schwab offers an Individual 401(k) for self-employed owners with no full-time employees other than a spouse. Schwab charges $0 to open or maintain the account, with a $0 minimum opening deposit, and online trades for stocks and ETFs carry no commission. The plan supports both pre-tax and Roth employee contributions, and employer contributions of up to 25 percent of compensation are allowed, within IRS limits.
The trade-off is scope: the plan does not allow participant loans, in-plan Roth rollover conversions, nondeductible employee contributions or Mega Backdoor Roth strategies, and it covers only traditional brokerage investments, not real estate or private equity. The owner must file Form 5500 once plan assets reach $250,000, and Schwab does not file it for you. For a solo owner who wants a no-cost account and a broad brokerage menu, it is hard to beat on price, as long as the missing features do not matter.

Ideal for: Flat annual fee up to 30 staff
Employee Fiduciary is a low-cost, full-service 401k provider aimed at businesses with 30 employees or fewer. The annual base fee is $1,500 and covers up to 30 eligible employees, with $30 per year for each employee above 30, plus a 0.08 percent custody fee on plan assets. A new plan carries a $500 establishment fee and a conversion carries a $1,000 fee. Employees are not charged separate recordkeeping fees, which keeps the fee picture simple.
The service includes plan design consultation, setup, compliance and nondiscrimination testing, and a dedicated relationship manager, with access to low-cost index funds including Vanguard options. The flat fee is best value near 30 staff, since the same $1,500 covers 10 people or 30. Watch the per-event charges: distributions cost $50 each, loan origination and annual maintenance cost $50 each, and plan document amendments cost $150, so a team with frequent distributions will see extra bills.

Ideal for: First-time plans through payroll
Vestwell runs a modern recordkeeping platform that many payroll providers and advisers use to offer 401k plans. Its Starter(k) plan costs $49 per month plus $8 per active participant per month, with a 0.20 percent asset-based investment management fee. Workplace costs $125 per month plus $8 per participant, and Plus costs $175 per month plus $8 per participant, both with the same 0.20 percent asset fee. A Solo(k) for self-employed owners costs $45 per month plus a 0.30 percent asset fee.
Starter(k) is for first-time plans only, with a preset plan design, self-service digital setup and a $6,000 employee contribution limit, while Workplace adds Safe Harbor options and a $24,500 contribution limit for 2026. Plus adds flexible plan design and covers plan transfers. Fees are charged on participants with an active balance, not on every eligible employee, and the employer can choose to cover participant fees or pass them to employees. Confirm which payroll providers qualify for Starter(k) before you commit.
| Team size | Pick | Why | Typical employer cost | | Owner only, no staff | Charles Schwab | No setup or annual account fee | $0 per month | | 2 to 10 employees | Guideline Starter | Lowest monthly base fee | $59 to $79 per month | | 11 to 30 employees | Employee Fiduciary | Flat annual fee covers the whole team | $125 per month | | 31 to 50 employees | Employee Fiduciary | Only $30 per year for each employee above 30 | $125 to $175 per month | | Any size, fund cost first | Vanguard VRPA | Lowest fund expense ratios | $4,850 per year for up to 15 participants |
Use this table as a starting point, then check the participant fees, because they change the ranking. At 10 employees, Guideline Starter costs $79 per month to the employer, Human Interest Essentials costs $130 and Betterment Essential costs $150, before any participant asset fees. At 25 employees, Employee Fiduciary still costs $125 per month to the employer, while Human Interest Essentials costs $205 and Guideline Core costs $289. A solo owner should start with Schwab or Fidelity, since both charge no account fee for an owner-only plan.
We compared the eight providers on their own pricing pages, plan documents and feature lists, checked on 13 November 2026. We recorded the entry tier monthly base fee and per-participant fee for each provider, plus setup fees, asset-based fees and participant charges, and we noted where a vendor publishes prices and where it quotes per plan. We favored providers with published pricing, payroll integration, compliance support and a fund lineup with low expense ratios. We did not test any product hands-on and we did not rely on review scores, awards or customer counts. Where a vendor page did not show a price, we used the vendor's own fee disclosure document or a second source that cited the vendor page, and we say so in the research notes.
Ask each provider for a written fee schedule that shows employer fees and participant fees separately, including setup, recordkeeping, advisory and transaction charges. Confirm who files Form 5500, who runs nondiscrimination testing and who acts as 3(16) fiduciary, since the entry tier at several providers leaves those tasks with you. Check the contribution limit on the entry tier: Starter plans at Guideline and Vestwell cap employee contributions at $6,000, far below the $24,500 limit for 2026 on full plans. Confirm payroll integration with the exact payroll product you use, and ask whether the provider charges extra to connect it. Finally, check the fund lineup expense ratios and whether employer matching or profit sharing is included, because a low base fee can hide higher asset-based charges.
Entry plans in this guide start from $39 to $100 per month in base fees, plus $4 to $8 per participant per month, before asset-based fees. At 10 employees, Guideline Starter costs $79 per month, Human Interest Essentials costs $130 and Betterment Essential costs $150. Setup fees range from $0 to $500, and participants usually pay an asset-based fee of 0.06 to 0.25 percent per year.
Guideline Starter is cheapest on employer base fees at 10 employees, at $79 per month, followed by Human Interest Essentials at $130 and Betterment Essential at $150. Fidelity Advantage costs $100 per month plus a $500 setup fee, but participants pay $25 per quarter. The cheapest headline price is not always the cheapest total, so add participant recordkeeping and advisory fees before you decide.
Yes. Schwab and Fidelity both offer owner-only 401k accounts with no setup or annual account fee, and Vestwell offers a Solo(k) at $45 per month. An owner-only plan allows employee deferrals plus employer contributions of up to 25 percent of compensation, within IRS limits. These plans are only for owners with no full-time employees other than a spouse, so hiring staff means moving to an employer plan.
The 2026 employee contribution limit is $24,500, with an extra catch-up amount for employees age 50 and older. Entry Starter plans are the exception: Guideline Starter and Vestwell Starter(k) both cap employee contributions at $6,000, which suits a first plan but limits saving. If your team wants the full limit, choose a Core, Workplace or equivalent tier and confirm the limit in writing.
Yes, at most providers. Participants commonly pay a recordkeeping fee, an advisory fee, or both, either as a monthly amount or as a percentage of assets. Human Interest charges 0.06 percent per month in total asset-based fees, Betterment charges 0.25 percent per year, and Fidelity charges $25 per quarter plus 0.125 percent. Employee Fiduciary is the exception here, since it charges no separate participant recordkeeping fee.
Most modern providers in this guide can set up a first plan in 2 to 4 weeks once payroll is connected and plan documents are signed. Guideline and Vestwell offer self-service digital setup, while Fidelity and Vanguard involve more plan design discussion and can take longer. Converting an existing plan takes longer than starting fresh, since assets must transfer and documents must be restated, so allow extra time.