Comparing 5 Healthcare Staffing Software Options in 2026

A
By the Ainotely Editorial Team.
Updated November 2026. 7 min read. Prices and features researched from each vendor's official pages and app store listings at time of writing.
Comparing 5 Healthcare Staffing Software Options
Quick picks
  1. 1CareRev logo
    CareRevHospitals that want to cut premium agency labor
    Visit
  2. 2Nursa logo
    NursaSkilled nursing facilities, rehab centers and hospitals that want direct facility-to-clinician shift filling
    Visit
  3. 3ShiftKey logo
    ShiftKeySkilled nursing and post-acute facilities that require local PRN coverage without signing agency contracts
    Visit
  4. 4Bullhorn logo
    BullhornHealthcare staffing agencies that require a single ATS and CRM to run recruiting
    Visit
  5. 5Aya Healthcare logo
    Aya HealthcareHealth systems and large facilities that want one tech-enabled agency for travel
    Visit
Short version:
In this guide Direct answerQuick comparisonThe 5 tools in detailHow the list was put togetherBefore you commitFrequently asked questionsSources

Direct answer

Start with CareRev if you need Hospitals that want to cut premium agency labor. For a different need, Nursa covers skilled nursing facilities, rehab centers and hospitals that want direct facility-to-clinician shift filling and ShiftKey covers skilled nursing and post-acute facilities. Prices, free plans and limits for all 5 tools follow.

Quick comparison

ProductIdeal forPrice fromFree version
CareRevHospitals that want to cut premium agency laborSee website (per-shift, quote-based)NoVisit
NursaSkilled nursing facilities, rehab centers and hospitals that want direct facility-to-clinician shift fillingSee website (facilities set per-shift rates, pay per filled shift)NoVisit
ShiftKeySkilled nursing and post-acute facilities that require local PRN coverage without signing agency contractsSee website (per-shift, quote-based)NoVisit
BullhornHealthcare staffing agencies that require a single ATS and CRM to run recruiting$99 per user per month (Starter)NoVisit
Aya HealthcareHealth systems and large facilities that want one tech-enabled agency for travelSee website (quote-based per assignment)NoVisit

The 5 tools in detail

Choosing healthcare staffing software usually comes down to price, fit and limits. This Ainotely guide sets 5 tools side by side on those three points, with the facts kept short and checkable.

CareRev logo
#1

CareRev

Ideal for: Hospitals that want to cut premium agency labor

CareRev website
carerev.com homepage

CareRev is built with Hospitals that want to cut premium agency labor in mind. Joint Commission certification matters for hospital compliance teams.

Reasons to shortlist it: Joint Commission certified.

Drawbacks to consider: Coverage is concentrated in major metro areas.

CareRev does not show a starting price in this comparison, so check the vendor site for current pricing. CareRev has no free plan.

The good and the bad
  • Purpose-built for acute care hospitals: internal staff self-schedule first
  • Hospitals keep rate control inside the product
  • Acquired by IntelyCare in January 2026, so the product roadmap is in transition
Nursa logo
#2

Nursa

Ideal for: Skilled nursing facilities, rehab centers and hospitals that want direct facility-to-clinician shift filling

Nursa website
nursa.com homepage

Nursa is a good fit for skilled nursing facilities, rehab centers and hospitals that want direct facility-to-clinician shift filling with no agency middleman. Nursa cuts the middleman: facilities post shifts at rates they set, choose from verified local clinicians, and pay only for filled shifts. More specifically, the honest catch is supply uncertainty in thin markets; urgent shifts can go unclaimed outside solid coverage areas.

Where it is weaker: not a full workforce management suite.

It also does not replace enterprise scheduling, timekeeping or credentialing programs. The no-hire-away-fee policy is a genuine differentiator: try a clinician on PRN shifts, then hire the best ones permanently without a buyout penalty. For facilities that want rate control and a hiring pipeline from their PRN pool, the economics beat agency markup. This comparison lists no price for Nursa; ask the vendor. No free plan comes with Nursa.

The good and the bad
  • Direct model with transparent facility-set pricing and no agency markup
  • Favorite pools and auto-scheduling
  • Supply depth varies by city
ShiftKey logo
#3

ShiftKey

Ideal for: Skilled nursing and post-acute facilities that require local PRN coverage without signing agency contracts

ShiftKey app screenshots
App Store screenshots

Pick ShiftKey if this describes you: skilled nursing and post-acute facilities that need local PRN coverage without signing agency contracts. ShiftKey is the on-demand marketplace model: facilities post PRN shifts, credentialed professionals bid or claim them, and both sides skip the recruiter.

Reasons to shortlist it: Professionals set their own rates and choose shifts with no minimum hours.

For everyday use, professionals control their rates and schedules; facilities get coverage without agency contracts. This comparison lists no price for ShiftKey; ask the vendor. There is no free plan with ShiftKey. The main drawbacks: Shift cancellations by facilities are a recurring complaint in reviews.

The good and the bad
  • One of the largest PRN healthcare marketplaces
  • Therapists and dental roles
  • Quality varies by market
Bullhorn logo
#4

Bullhorn

Ideal for: Healthcare staffing agencies that require a single ATS and CRM to run recruiting

For Healthcare staffing agencies that require a single ATS and CRM to run recruiting and sales, Bullhorn is a natural candidate. Bullhorn is the agency-side tool: it is designed for staffing businesses, not hospitals. Worth adding: free implementation on small-agency plans gets teams live in under two weeks.

Starter at $99 per user a month and Core at $165 include tracking, email and the marketplace. Pro and Max with the Amplify AI layer are quote-based. In practice, Healthcare staffing agencies placing travel nurses and allied clinicians get purpose-built workflows for submissions, tearsheets and client management. Bullhorn pricing: $99 per user per month. Bullhorn has no free tier.

Where it is weaker: Extras and annual uplifts can push the contract well above the seat price; Real AI and automation sit on quote-only levels.

The good and the bad
  • 300-plus partner marketplace and LinkedIn integrations
  • Amplify AI features (search and match, staffing LLM, call transcription) on upper levels
  • Not the full product
Aya Healthcare logo
#5

Aya Healthcare

Ideal for: Health systems and large facilities that want one tech-enabled agency for travel

Aya Healthcare is built with health systems and large facilities that want one tech-enabled agency for travel in mind. Aya is a staffing agency first and a software second. Pricing is quote-based per assignment.

In daily use, enterprise workforce options manage MSP-style programs for health systems. In daily use, facilities contract through its system for travel nurses, allied health, locum tenens and local PRN, whereas clinicians browse jobs and pay packages in the app. This comparison lists no price for Aya Healthcare; ask the vendor. Aya Healthcare has no permanent free option.

Limits to weigh: It is an agency relationship.

The good and the bad
  • Enterprise workforce options sit on the same product
  • Paired with a self-serve digital job system
  • Not software you install

How the list was put together

Ainotely used vendor pricing pages and product documentation as the base, then compared plans, free access and documented limits for 5 tools. Figures are shown as the vendors publish them. Billing terms, seat minimums and add-ons can change the real cost. The ranking is editorial: typical fit first, then clear pricing, then free access. If your needs are unusual, read the profiles rather than relying on position.

Before you commit

Frequently asked questions

Is CareRev the right pick for everyone comparing healthcare staffing software?

No single tool suits every team. CareRev comes first because it fits Hospitals that want to cut premium agency labor, while Nursa suits skilled nursing facilities, rehab centers and hospitals that want direct facility-to-clinician shift filling and ShiftKey suits skilled nursing and post-acute facilities that need local PRN coverage without signing agency contracts. Match the tool to your own size, budget and workflow before deciding.

Do I need an agency or a marketplace?

An agency (like Aya Healthcare) manages sourcing, credentialing and fulfillment for you at the highest cost. In daily use, a marketplace (ShiftKey, Nursa, CareRev) lets you post shifts and choose clinicians yourself at lower cost but with more management work.

Does any tool for healthcare staffing software here have a free plan?

A permanent free plan is not offered by CareRev, Aya Healthcare or the other tools here. Plan a short evaluation period instead.

How are the tools for healthcare staffing software ordered?

The order follows typical fit for healthcare staffing software, with CareRev first and Aya Healthcare last, then price clarity and free access. It is editorial judgement, not a score, so another team could rank the tools differently.

What is the difference between ShiftKey and Nursa?

Both are PRN marketplaces connecting facilities with clinicians. Nursa emphasizes direct facility-to-clinician matching with facility-set rates and no hire-away fees, so facilities can convert PRN clinicians to permanent hires.

Do these tools publish their prices?

Not all of them. CareRev, Nursa, ShiftKey and Aya Healthcare publish no starting price, so expect a quote request for those. The rest, Bullhorn included, show a starting price, though seats and billing terms still change the final cost.

Sources

  1. https://www.carerev.com/
  2. https://nursa.com/
  3. https://shiftkey.com/
  4. https://www.bullhorn.com/
  5. https://www.ayahealthcare.com/