| Product | Ideal for | Price from | Free version | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| solo employers who want guided payroll | See website | Free trial | Visit | |
| employers already using Square | See website | Free trial | Visit | |
| employers who want low cost payroll | See website | Free trial | Visit | |
| employers who want clear affordable payroll | See website | Free trial | Visit | |
| employers who want simple online payroll | See website | Free trial | Visit | |
| employers who want payroll plus HR basics | See website | Free trial | Visit | |
| employers who want broad support | See website | No | Visit |
Paying even one employee involves tax withholding, filings, pay stubs and deadlines, so a payroll service that automates those steps saves time and errors. We compared official product pages, pricing pages and public reviews, focusing on tax filing, ease of use, employee self service and pricing model. Pricing is often per month plus per employee, so we note the model rather than quoting a figure we could not confirm.

Ideal for: solo employers who want guided payroll

Gusto is a popular payroll choice for small employers, with guided setup, automatic federal and state tax filings, pay stubs and employee self service for pay and documents. Its interface suits an owner who runs payroll for one employee and wants the steps explained clearly. Benefits and contractor payments can be added as the business grows.
Before you pay, check the limits that apply to your own use, including seats, storage, monthly usage and support hours. A plan that looks generous on the headline page can still cap the one feature you rely on most, so read the plan comparison page rather than the marketing summary. A trial or free tier is the safest way to test this, and it also shows whether support answers promptly when you need help.
Pricing is monthly plus per employee, so even one employee carries a base fee, and benefits administration is extra. Check which tax filings are included for your state, and confirm the total monthly cost before signing.

Ideal for: employers already using Square

Square Payroll offers simple payroll with automatic tax filings, pay stubs and employee self service, integrated with Square POS and payments for businesses already using Square. That integration suits a shop owner who already takes payments through Square and now hires a first employee. Its setup is among the simplest for a single employee.
The price on the headline page is only part of the cost, so check renewal pricing, per-seat charges and any paid add-ons before you commit. Free tiers help for light use, but they often cap the features that matter once work grows, and trials end on a fixed date whether you have finished testing or not. Set a reminder before a trial ends, and confirm cancellation steps in advance so you are not locked into a plan you no longer need.
Its feature range is narrower than Gusto for benefits and HR, so a growing team may outgrow it. Check state tax filing coverage and whether contractor payments are included at your plan level.

Ideal for: employers who want low cost payroll

Wave Payroll, part of Wave accounting, offers payroll with tax filings and pay stubs at a lower cost than many rivals, integrated with Wave invoicing and accounting. That suits a solo employer who already uses Wave for books and wants payroll in the same place. Its simple flow covers a single employee well.
Pricing is where many readers get caught out, so look past the headline figure and check what the plan actually includes for your level of use. Seats, usage limits, add-ons and renewal terms can change the real monthly cost, and a cheaper plan that lacks one feature you need is not a saving. If a free tier or trial is offered, use it for real work before paying, and confirm how cancellation works while you still have time to change your mind.
Availability varies by state, and support is mainly online, so check coverage for your state before relying on it. Confirm which federal and state filings are automated, and test employee self service during a trial.

Ideal for: employers who want clear affordable payroll
Patriot Software offers payroll with clear pricing, automatic tax filings, pay stubs and employee self service, plus US based support by phone and chat. Its straightforward approach suits a solo employer who wants to understand exactly what payroll costs and what it covers. Accounting integration is available for bookkeeping.
Before you pay, check the limits that apply to your own use, including seats, storage, monthly usage and support hours. A plan that looks generous on the headline page can still cap the one feature you rely on most, so read the plan comparison page rather than the marketing summary. A trial or free tier is the safest way to test this, and it also shows whether support answers promptly when you need help.
Its interface is functional rather than polished, and HR features are basic compared with Gusto. Check state coverage, and confirm whether direct deposit and tax filings for your state are included.

Ideal for: employers who want simple online payroll
SurePayroll, part of Paychex, offers simple online payroll with tax filings, pay stubs and mobile access for small employers. Its focus on core payroll suits a solo employer who does not need a full HR suite. The service has a long history in small business payroll.
The price on the headline page is only part of the cost, so check renewal pricing, per-seat charges and any paid add-ons before you commit. Free tiers help for light use, but they often cap the features that matter once work grows, and trials end on a fixed date whether you have finished testing or not. Set a reminder before a trial ends, and confirm cancellation steps in advance so you are not locked into a plan you no longer need.
Its feature range is basic compared with broader HR platforms, and pricing varies by plan and features. Get a quote for one employee, and check which filings and employee self service tools are included.

Ideal for: employers who want payroll plus HR basics
OnPay combines payroll with basic HR tools, including onboarding, document storage and benefits administration, with automatic tax filings. Its single price model suits a solo employer who wants payroll plus a little HR without tier confusion. Employee self service covers pay, documents and time off.
Pricing is where many readers get caught out, so look past the headline figure and check what the plan actually includes for your level of use. Seats, usage limits, add-ons and renewal terms can change the real monthly cost, and a cheaper plan that lacks one feature you need is not a saving. If a free tier or trial is offered, use it for real work before paying, and confirm how cancellation works while you still have time to change your mind.
It is a smaller brand than Gusto or Paychex, so check references and state coverage. Confirm benefits administration options and pricing for your state before committing.

Ideal for: employers who want broad support
Paychex Flex offers payroll, tax filings, HR, benefits and retirement tools through a large provider with a wide support network. A solo employer who plans to grow may value starting with a provider that scales to many employees. Its payroll covers federal and state filings with employee self service.
Before you pay, check the limits that apply to your own use, including seats, storage, monthly usage and support hours. A plan that looks generous on the headline page can still cap the one feature you rely on most, so read the plan comparison page rather than the marketing summary. A trial or free tier is the safest way to test this, and it also shows whether support answers promptly when you need help.
Pricing is quoted, so a one employee employer should get a full quote and compare it with simpler services. Check which HR features are included, and confirm the cost as headcount grows.
We compared official feature pages, pricing pages, app store listings, privacy policies and public reviews for each option in this guide. We kept only products that exist and work in October 2026 and that fit the topic directly, and we checked that each official homepage loads and belongs to the product named. Prices and free tiers are taken from the vendor site where we could verify them, and we wrote See website where a price could not be confirmed, rather than guessing. Our pick in each guide reflects fit for ordinary readers, not a claim of hands-on testing, and we note the honest limits of each option alongside its strengths.
Start by listing your state, pay frequency and whether the employee is salaried or hourly, since state tax filings and overtime rules vary. A service that automates federal and state filings for your state is essential, even for one employee, because missed filings bring penalties. Test the setup flow, including employee onboarding and direct deposit, before your first pay run.
Compare total monthly cost, including base fee, per employee fee and any tax filing charges, and check what happens if you miss a pay run or need to correct one. Keep pay stubs and tax records organised, and set a calendar reminder for quarterly filings even if the service automates them. A payroll service should reduce worry, not add a new admin job.
Gusto and Square Payroll suit simple guided payroll, Wave suits low cost payroll with accounting, and Patriot and SurePayroll suit clear affordable payroll. OnPay suits payroll plus HR basics, while Paychex suits employers planning to grow.
Most services charge a monthly base fee plus a per employee fee, with tax filings included at most plan levels. Get a quote for one employee in your state, and check for setup, tax filing and year end form charges.
Yes in most cases, since payroll software automates tax withholding, filings, pay stubs and year end forms, reducing error and penalty risk. Manual payroll is possible for one employee, but the time and risk usually outweigh the software cost.
Employers generally withhold federal and state income tax, Social Security and Medicare, and pay employer shares plus unemployment taxes, with rules varying by state. A payroll service calculates and files these, but the employer remains responsible for accuracy.
Yes, but you must calculate withholding, file federal and state returns on time, issue pay stubs and year end forms, and keep records. Payroll software automates most of this, which is why most solo employers use a service even for one employee.