For districts seeking substitute staffing services, Edustaff is where this list starts. Look at Kelly Education for institutions needing thorough workforce options, and at Swing Education for districts needing on-demand substitute staffing. The remaining 2 options are covered below with prices and limits.
If you are comparing software for managing substitute teacher placement, this page covers 5 tools in one place: what each is best for, what it costs to start, whether it has a free plan, and the main limit to know about.
Key takeaways
Edustaff is the opening pick, best for districts seeking substitute staffing services.
Edustaff comes with a trade-off: restricted public information on software features.
Pricing across the list, from Edustaff to Red Rover, is by quote only.
For schools seeking unified absence and substitute management, Red Rover is worth a look.
Edustaff, Red Rover and the 3 others all need a premium plan or a trial, since no free plan is listed.
Best for: Districts seeking substitute staffing services
Edustaff is aimed squarely at districts seeking substitute staffing services. Edustaff is a solid fit for schools that prefer to partner with an external agency for substitute staffing instead of handling it entirely in-house.
On top of that, as a staffing service, Edustaff may not offer a software product for districts to handle absences directly. Also, districts should evaluate whether they need a software option or a staffing partner. Edustaff does not show a starting price in this comparison, so check the vendor site for current pricing. Trial and free access: Not stated.
Trade-offs to know: Restricted public information on software features.
Best for: Institutions needing thorough workforce options
Kelly Education serves institutions needing thorough workforce options. Kelly Education gives you education staffing and workforce options, helping schools and institutions address recruiting, hiring, and staffing needs. It powers the education workforce for numerous schools, offering a mix of services beyond substitute placement.
Consider if you need a software tool or a staffing partner. Worth adding: Kelly Education is primarily a staffing services provider. So it may not offer the same software features for absence management as dedicated systems. It could be a better fit for districts looking to outsource staffing functions rather than run them in-house. On top of that, the platform is suited for institutions that require thorough support in building and managing their education workforce, including substitute teachers. Pricing for Kelly Education is not stated here, so ask the vendor for current figures. On free options: Not stated.
Highlights: Serves a large number of schools and institutions. The main drawbacks: May be more than needed for small districts.
Best for: Districts needing on-demand substitute staffing
Swing Education was built for districts needing on-demand substitute staffing. Swing Education helps K-12 school districts fill absences rapidly with vetted substitute teachers, paraprofessionals, and classified staff. Districts should consider whether they need a full software option or staffing support.
The service contains budget tools to help administrators run staffing costs. It is built for districts that require on-demand staffing support, particularly when internal substitute pools are insufficient. Pricing for Swing Education is not stated here, so ask the vendor for current figures. As for free access: Not stated.
Limits to weigh: Focus on staffing instead of software management.
Best for: K-12 districts needing integrated absence management
Frontline Absence Management (Aesop) is designed for K-12 districts needing integrated absence management. The product is aimed at schools that want an integrated approach, connecting absence management with other administrative functions.
If you need a more straightforward, dedicated substitute placement tool, other choices may be more suitable. Frontline Absence Management (Aesop) shows no starting price here, so confirm the cost on the vendor site. Trial and free access: Not stated.
The main drawbacks: Restricted standalone use without other Frontline modules.
Best for: Schools seeking unified absence and substitute management
Choose Red Rover for schools seeking unified absence and substitute management. If you need deep integration with other administrative systems, consider a more full system.
In daily use, since in-depth feature information is not widely publicized, districts should request a demo to evaluate if it meets their specific requirements. Check the vendor site for Red Rover pricing; none is listed in this comparison. As for free access: Not stated.
Where it falls short: Restricted public information on specific features.
Confirm the entry price with every vendor: no tool from Edustaff to Red Rover shows a fixed starting price.
Read the limits listed for Edustaff first: restricted public information on software features.
Before rolling out Swing Education, verify the integrations your workflow depends on.
Find out what support Frontline Absence Management (Aesop) includes on your plan, and whether onboarding help costs extra.
Check whether Red Rover bills monthly or annually, and what cancelling early costs.
How we picked
The comparison looks at four things: starting price, free access, how well the feature set matches software for managing substitute teacher placement, and the main limit of each tool. Where a vendor does not publish a price, the entry says quote. Where a price depends on seats or billing term, the entry says so. The sequence is a judgement call: typical use case first, then pricing transparency, then free access. Use the profiles to check fit.
Every price and plan detail on this page comes from the vendors’ own websites. We did not run hands-on tests unless the text says so, and we do not publish star ratings or review scores. See how we score and our disclosure.
Keep your shortlist in one place
Paste prices, trial dates and notes from this guide into Ainotely, our AI note app. It files them into a topic and pulls out tasks like “cancel trial by Friday”. Free 7-day trial, no card needed.
Not by default. None of the tools, from Edustaff to Red Rover, lists a free plan or a free trial here, so ask each vendor for a demo before committing.
Do these tools publish their prices?
No. None of the tools, from Edustaff to Red Rover, shows a fixed starting price here, so budget time for quotes.
How does Frontline Absence Management compare to Red Rover?
Frontline Absence Management is part of a broader K-12 administration suite, whereas Red Rover focuses specifically on absence and substitute management. Frontline may be better for districts wanting an integrated system, whereas Red Rover gives you a dedicated option.
Is Edustaff the right pick for everyone comparing software for managing substitute teacher placement?
No single tool suits every team. Edustaff comes first because it fits districts seeking substitute staffing services, while Kelly Education suits institutions needing comprehensive workforce solutions and Swing Education suits districts needing on-demand substitute staffing. Match the tool to your own size, budget and workflow before deciding.
Does any tool for software for managing substitute teacher placement here have a free plan?
No tool in this list, Edustaff and Red Rover included, has a permanent free plan. Trials and quotes are the usual route, so plan a short evaluation period.