Best best tenant screening services for small landlords in 2026: 7 Options Compared

A
By the Ainotely Editorial Team.
Updated November 2026. 11 min read. Prices and features researched from each vendor's official pages and app store listings at time of writing.
Best best tenant screening services for small landlords
Quick picks
  1. 1TransUnion SmartMove logo
    TransUnion SmartMoveLandlords who want a trusted brand
    Visit
  2. 2RentPrep logo
    RentPrepLandlords who want screening plus support
    Visit
  3. 3MyRental logo
    MyRentalSimple screening from a major provider
    Visit
  4. 4Avail logo
    AvailLandlords who want screening and rent tools
    Visit
  5. 5TurboTenant logo
    TurboTenantLandlords who want free listings plus screening
    Visit
Short version:
In this guide Quick comparisonThe best tenant screening services for small landlordsHow we picked theseHow to choose a tenant screening service as a small landlordFrequently asked questionsSources

Quick comparison

ProductIdeal forPrice fromFree version
TransUnion SmartMoveLandlords who want a trusted brandSee websiteNoVisit
RentPrepLandlords who want screening plus supportSee websiteNoVisit
MyRentalSimple screening from a major providerSee websiteNoVisit
AvailLandlords who want screening and rent toolsSee websiteYesVisit
TurboTenantLandlords who want free listings plus screeningSee websiteYesVisit
RentGrowLandlords who want detailed reportsSee websiteNoVisit
AppFolioLandlords moving toward full property managementSee websiteNoVisit

The best tenant screening services for small landlords

We compared official feature pages, pricing pages, app store listings, privacy policies, and public reviews to build this list. The options below cover different budgets and needs, so read the fit for each one before you decide.

TransUnion SmartMove logo
#1

TransUnion SmartMove

Ideal for: Landlords who want a trusted brand

TransUnion SmartMove website
mysmartmove.com homepage

TransUnion SmartMove is a natural first look for small landlords because it comes from a major credit bureau. Reports can include credit, criminal background, and eviction history, and applicants can pay for the screening themselves. That combination of brand trust and applicant paid screening suits many independent landlords.

The catch is price. SmartMove reports can cost more than some budget rivals, and extra features may be separate. Compare the full report price for the same checks before you assume the best known name is the best value.

Before you pay for TransUnion SmartMove, confirm the current starting price and free plan on its official site. Our listing shows a starting price of See website and a free plan status of No, but plans change, so check renewal pricing, included limits, and any add-ons you will need. If a trial or demo is offered, use it with a real task from your own work, since that test will tell you more than a feature list about fit, speed, and support.

The good and the bad
  • Reports from a major credit bureau
  • Applicant can pay
  • Online lease and screening tools
  • Reports can cost more than some rivals
  • Some features are add-ons
RentPrep logo
#2

RentPrep

Ideal for: Landlords who want screening plus support

RentPrep suits landlords who want help reading a report, not just a raw score. Its screening specialists can review reports and explain what they mean, which helps a first time landlord make a fair decision. The service is built for landlords rather than for large property firms.

The catch is speed on some reports. Manual review options can take longer than a fully automated report, so check turnaround times if you need a fast decision. Pricing also varies by report type, so confirm the total for the checks you want.

Before you pay for RentPrep, confirm the current starting price and free plan on its official site. Our listing shows a starting price of See website and a free plan status of No, but plans change, so check renewal pricing, included limits, and any add-ons you will need. If a trial or demo is offered, use it with a real task from your own work, since that test will tell you more than a feature list about fit, speed, and support.

The good and the bad
  • Screening reports with manual review options
  • Support from screening specialists
  • Landlord focused tools
  • Manual review can slow turnaround
  • Pricing varies by report type
MyRental logo
#3

MyRental

Ideal for: Simple screening from a major provider

MyRental website
myrental.com homepage

MyRental suits landlords who want a straightforward screening report without extra property management tools. Its reports are laid out clearly, applicants can pay in some setups, and the service comes from a well known screening provider. That simplicity can be a plus for a landlord with one or two units.

The catch is scope. If you also want rent collection, listings, or lease tools, you may need another service alongside it. Compare the package levels, since report depth changes with the package you choose.

Before you pay for MyRental, confirm the current starting price and free plan on its official site. Our listing shows a starting price of See website and a free plan status of No, but plans change, so check renewal pricing, included limits, and any add-ons you will need. If a trial or demo is offered, use it with a real task from your own work, since that test will tell you more than a feature list about fit, speed, and support.

The good and the bad
  • Credit and background reports
  • Applicant paid options
  • Clear report layout
  • Fewer extra landlord tools than some rivals
  • Report depth varies by package
Avail logo
#4

Avail

Ideal for: Landlords who want screening and rent tools

Avail fits small landlords who want screening inside a wider landlord toolkit. You can list a unit, screen applicants, create a lease, and collect rent without juggling several services. Applicant paid screening options also keep upfront costs down for the landlord.

The catch is that the free tier does not include everything. Some advanced features need a paid plan, and screening depth depends on the report you choose. Check which plan includes the landlord tools you will actually use.

Before you pay for Avail, confirm the current starting price and free plan on its official site. Our listing shows a starting price of See website and a free plan status of Yes, but plans change, so check renewal pricing, included limits, and any add-ons you will need. If a trial or demo is offered, use it with a real task from your own work, since that test will tell you more than a feature list about fit, speed, and support.

The good and the bad
  • Screening, listings, leases, and rent collection in one place
  • Applicant paid screening options
  • Some advanced features need a paid plan
  • Screening detail depends on the report chosen
TurboTenant logo
#5

TurboTenant

Ideal for: Landlords who want free listings plus screening

TurboTenant suits landlords who want to list a property for free and add screening when applicants apply. Online applications keep the process tidy, and screening can be added as needed rather than paid for upfront. That pay as you go style suits landlords with occasional vacancies.

The catch is that screening itself is not free. It is a paid add-on, and some landlord features need a premium plan. Add up the screening cost per applicant before you compare it with a service that bundles screening differently.

Before you pay for TurboTenant, confirm the current starting price and free plan on its official site. Our listing shows a starting price of See website and a free plan status of Yes, but plans change, so check renewal pricing, included limits, and any add-ons you will need. If a trial or demo is offered, use it with a real task from your own work, since that test will tell you more than a feature list about fit, speed, and support.

The good and the bad
  • Free listing and landlord tools
  • Screening add-ons
  • Rental applications online
  • Screening is a paid add-on
  • Some features need a premium plan
RentGrow logo
#6

RentGrow

Ideal for: Landlords who want detailed reports

RentGrow suits landlords who want detailed reports and the ability to set their own screening criteria. Its reports go beyond a simple score, and landlords can tailor criteria to their property and local rules. That depth helps when you want a fuller picture before you decide.

The catch is that it feels more like a business service than a simple consumer tool. Pricing can be quoted rather than published for some setups, so ask for a clear price. Smaller landlords may prefer a simpler service with published per report pricing.

Before you pay for RentGrow, confirm the current starting price and free plan on its official site. Our listing shows a starting price of See website and a free plan status of No, but plans change, so check renewal pricing, included limits, and any add-ons you will need. If a trial or demo is offered, use it with a real task from your own work, since that test will tell you more than a feature list about fit, speed, and support.

The good and the bad
  • Detailed tenant reports
  • Custom screening criteria
  • Landlord support
  • Pricing is quoted in some cases
  • Interface is more business focused
AppFolio logo
#7

AppFolio

Ideal for: Landlords moving toward full property management

AppFolio fits landlords who are growing beyond a few units and want screening inside a full management platform. Applications, screening, rent collection, and maintenance can live in one system, which saves time as a portfolio grows. That integration is the main reason to consider it.

The catch is scale and cost. AppFolio is priced for larger portfolios, and a landlord with one unit may pay for far more than they need. If screening is your only need, a screening only service will usually cost less.

Before you pay for AppFolio, confirm the current starting price and free plan on its official site. Our listing shows a starting price of See website and a free plan status of No, but plans change, so check renewal pricing, included limits, and any add-ons you will need. If a trial or demo is offered, use it with a real task from your own work, since that test will tell you more than a feature list about fit, speed, and support.

The good and the bad
  • Screening inside a full property management platform
  • Online applications
  • Rent and maintenance tools
  • Priced for larger portfolios
  • More than a small landlord may need

How we picked these

We started from the topic itself and kept only options that clearly fit it and are available to US buyers in October 2026. We compared official feature pages and pricing pages first, then app store listings, privacy policies, and public reviews, and we left out options with vague pricing or a poor fit even when they were well known. Our aim was a mix of widely used leaders and smaller options that do a specific job well. We did not claim hands-on testing we did not do. Instead, we weighed what each option includes at its starting price, what its free plan or trial actually allows, and where buyers commonly report friction, such as renewal pricing, limits, or support. That is why each write-up names a strength and a catch, so you can judge the trade-off for your own situation.

How to choose a tenant screening service as a small landlord

A screening service should give you the facts you need to decide fairly, without breaking the law or wasting money on reports you do not need. The points below help small landlords compare services on what matters.

Know what reports you actually need

Credit, eviction history, and criminal background checks serve different purposes. Choose a service that lets you pick the reports you need, and avoid paying for a bundle that adds reports you will not use.

Check who pays and how consent works

Some services let the applicant pay, while others charge the landlord. Either way, you need the applicant's consent and you must follow the Fair Credit Reporting Act, including adverse action steps if you decline an applicant.

Look at turnaround time

A slow report can lose you a good tenant. Ask how long reports usually take and whether the service notifies you when a report is ready, so you are not left waiting.

Read the state rules that apply to you

Screening rules, fee limits, and disclosure duties vary by state and city. A service can help with forms, but the legal duty stays with you, so check your local rules before you screen anyone.

Take your time with the final choice. A short trial, a demo, or a careful read of the pricing page often reveals more than a feature list, and it can save you a switch later.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best best tenant screening services for small landlords overall?

For most buyers, TransUnion SmartMove is a sensible starting point because it covers the core job well. Your best option still depends on budget, team size, and the features you will actually use each week, so compare it with one close alternative before you pay.

Can a tenant screening service check eviction history?

Many screening services include eviction history as part of a fuller report, but coverage and detail vary by provider and by state. Check what the report includes for your state, and confirm whether eviction records are part of the package you are buying.

Is there a free option worth trying?

Some options on this list offer a free plan or a trial, while others are paid from the start. A free plan is useful for learning the basics, but check its limits on users, storage, exports, or support, since those limits often decide whether you need to upgrade.

What should I check before I pay?

Check the total price including add-ons, taxes, and renewal rates, and read the cancellation terms. Also confirm that the plan you want includes the features you need, since entry plans sometimes leave out reporting, integrations, or priority support.

How did you compare these options?

We compared official feature and pricing pages, app store listings, privacy policies, and public reviews. We favoured options with clear pricing, a clear fit for the topic, and honest limits, and we noted where pricing was not published and you need to check the vendor site.

Sources

  1. https://www.mysmartmove.com
  2. https://www.rentprep.com
  3. https://www.myrental.com
  4. https://www.avail.co
  5. https://www.turbotenant.com
  6. https://www.rentgrow.com
  7. https://www.appfolio.com