| Product | Ideal for | Price from | Free version | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Growing stores with a large app ecosystem | See website | Free trial | Visit | |
| Beautiful stores for artists and makers | See website | Free trial | Visit | |
| A marketplace audience for makers | See website | No | Visit | |
| Self hosted stores on WordPress | Free | Yes | Visit | |
| Simple drag and drop stores | See website | Free trial | Visit | |
| Stores linked to Square payments | See website | Free | Visit | |
| Add a store to an existing site | See website | Free | Visit | |
| Selling digital and small physical goods | See website | No | Visit |
Big Cartel suits artists selling a small product range, but growing stores often need more payment, shipping, and marketing tools. The alternatives below cover marketplaces, hosted stores, and self hosted shops.

Ideal for: Growing stores with a large app ecosystem

Shopify is the standard hosted store platform, with a large app ecosystem, payment tools, and plans that scale from small to enterprise. It suits sellers outgrowing Big Cartel who need shipping, marketing, and inventory tools. The admin is polished.
Monthly costs plus transaction fees and paid themes add up. For growing stores, Shopify is our pick.

Ideal for: Beautiful stores for artists and makers

Squarespace pairs beautiful templates with built in commerce, domain, and hosting, which suits artists who want a polished store without many apps. Design tools are strong. It covers products, subscriptions, and digital goods.
Its app ecosystem is smaller than Shopify, and advanced commerce sits in higher plans. For design led stores, Squarespace is excellent.

Ideal for: A marketplace audience for makers

Etsy gives makers a built in audience searching for handmade and vintage goods, with simple listings and seller tools. It suits artists who want discovery without marketing a standalone store. Setup is quick.
Listing and transaction fees apply, and marketplace rules limit brand control. For marketplace selling, Etsy is the natural choice.

Ideal for: Self hosted stores on WordPress
WooCommerce turns WordPress into a store with full control and a large plugin library, with no monthly platform fee beyond hosting. It suits sellers who want ownership and customization. The community is huge.
You handle hosting, updates, and security, and setup takes effort. For control on WordPress, WooCommerce is the standard.

Ideal for: Simple drag and drop stores
Wix offers drag and drop store design with built in commerce and affordable plans. It suits small sellers who want a simple setup and a good looking store quickly. Templates cover many niches.
App depth is less than Shopify, and very large catalogs are harder to manage. For simple stores, Wix is a good fit.

Ideal for: Stores linked to Square payments
Square Online links a store to Square payments, with a free tier and simple setup. It suits sellers who already use Square in person and want an online store that shares inventory. The basics are solid.
Design flexibility is moderate, and advanced features cost more. For Square users, Online is convenient.

Ideal for: Add a store to an existing site
Ecwid adds a store to an existing website, blog, or social page, with a free tier and multi channel selling. It suits artists who already have a site and want to add commerce without rebuilding. Setup is quick.
Standalone store features are thinner than Shopify, and design is widget based. For adding commerce to a site, Ecwid is practical.

Ideal for: Selling digital and small physical goods
Gumroad suits creators selling digital goods, art, and small physical items with minimal setup. It handles payments and delivery simply. The creator focus fits Big Cartel artists.
Fees per sale apply, and physical product tools are basic. For simple creator sales, Gumroad is an easy option.
We compared official feature pages, pricing, and app ecosystems for each platform, checking store limits, payment options, and design tools. We favored platforms that state fees plainly. We did not claim hands-on testing; our comparison rests on published features and public reviews.
We also checked whether each option is still offered and supported, and we left out products with unclear pricing, broken pages, or a poor fit for the topic. Where a price or free tier could not be confirmed from the vendor site, we wrote See website rather than guessing. Readers should still check the vendor page before buying, since prices and plans change.
Count your products and growth plans. Big Cartel free plan limits product count, so a store with many items needs a platform without that cap. If you plan to grow, choose a platform that scales without forcing a painful migration later.
Check transaction and payment fees. Hosted platforms charge monthly fees plus payment processing, and some add transaction fees on top. Add up monthly fees, payment fees, and app costs for your sales volume to compare honestly.
Consider where your buyers come from. A marketplace such as Etsy brings built in traffic but charges listing and transaction fees. A standalone store gives you control but needs your own marketing. Many sellers use both: a store for brand and a marketplace for discovery.
Test the design tools before committing. Your store should look like your brand, not a template clone. Try the theme editor, check mobile appearance, and confirm you can use your own domain. A good design tool saves designer costs.
Before you pay, confirm the total cost for the first year, including any add ons, renewal prices, and fees that only appear at checkout. A low starting price can hide a higher renewal rate, and a free tier can limit the feature you need most. Write down the features you will use weekly, and pay only for those.
After you choose, give the option a fair trial with your real workload, not just a quick tour. Set a reminder to review it after two to four weeks, and note what worked, what annoyed you, and what you never used. That review tells you whether to keep, upgrade, or switch before a renewal locks you in.
If the option disappoints, switch sooner rather than later. Export your data first, check whether you can keep your account history or settings, and confirm any cancellation terms. A good provider makes leaving straightforward, and a difficult exit is itself useful information about the service.
Talk to people who already use the option before you commit, especially for a business purchase. A short conversation with a current user reveals support quality, setup effort, and daily friction that marketing pages omit. Ask what surprised them after the first month, since early impressions often differ from longer use.
Keep a simple record of why you chose the option, including the price you were quoted and the features that mattered. That note makes renewal talks easier and helps a colleague or future you understand the decision. If the price rises or a key feature changes, the note shows whether the original reasons still hold.
Finally, plan the first week of use before you pay. List the setup steps, the data you need to move, and the people who need access. A clear first week plan turns a promising choice into a working routine, and it exposes missing features while you can still change your mind.
Save the vendor support page and the cancellation instructions in the same place as your receipt. When something goes wrong, you will want support details at hand rather than searching for them under pressure. A tidy record saves time and keeps a small problem from becoming a long one.
Keep notes on the first month of use, including any issues and how support handled them. Those notes give you clear evidence if you need a refund, an upgrade, or a switch, and they help you advise a friend or colleague who asks about the same choice later.
Shopify is our pick for growing stores, with a large app ecosystem and payment tools. Squarespace suits artists who want beautiful design, while Etsy is best for marketplace discovery. Your product count and growth plans decide the winner.
For larger stores, yes. Shopify offers more products, payment options, apps, and marketing tools, but costs more monthly. Big Cartel remains simpler and cheaper for very small artist shops. Choose based on size and needs.
Yes, many sellers do both. Etsy brings marketplace traffic, while your own store builds brand and customer lists. Managing inventory across both takes care, and tools can help sync stock.
Costs include the new monthly plan, payment fees, theme or app costs, and time to migrate products and redirect your domain. Some platforms offer migration tools or help. Budget a few weeks for a careful move.
A marketplace suits makers who want built in buyers and simple setup. Your own store suits sellers who want brand control, customer data, and lower per sale fees over time. Many sellers start on a marketplace and add a store later.
Review it at least once a year, and sooner if your needs, budget, or team size change. Prices, features, and policies shift over time, and a better fit may appear. A short yearly check, comparing your current option with two alternatives, keeps you from paying for features you no longer use.