Google Workspace Vault leads the list, best for Archiving for Google Workspace. Alternatives: Barracuda Email Archiving for Email protection and archiving bundle, and Smarsh Enterprise Archive for multi-channel communications archiving. All 5 tools are compared below on price, free plan and limits.
Choosing email Archiving software for compliance retention usually comes down to price, fit and limits. This Ainotely guide sets 5 tools side by side on those three points, with the facts kept short and checkable.
Key takeaways
This list starts with Google Workspace Vault, which is built for Archiving for Google Workspace.
What to know about Mimecast Email Archiving first: may be complicated for basic archiving needs.
Proofpoint Enterprise Archive fits intent-based protection and archiving.
A permanent free plan is missing from all 5 tools, Google Workspace Vault and Proofpoint Enterprise Archive included; plan for a trial or a premium start.
Google Workspace Vault is a good fit for Archiving for Google Workspace. Vault is only available for Google Workspace users, so it is not a good match for mixed environments. In practice, Google Workspace Vault is an archiving and eDiscovery tool for Google Workspace customers.
What to check first: May lack advanced features of dedicated archives.
It permits organizations to retain, search, and export email and other data for compliance. Whereas it handles entry-level retention and eDiscovery, it may not offer the depth of specialized archiving solutions. Google Workspace Vault shows no starting price here, so confirm the cost on the vendor site. Trial and free access: Not stated.
Barracuda Email Archiving is aimed squarely at Email protection and archiving bundle. It supplies cloud-based archiving with a focus on safeguarding email data. Beyond that, if you need a dedicated archiving option with transparent compliance features, consider other choices.
The option is suitable for organizations already using Barracuda products or those seeking an integrated security and archiving approach. It is often used by companies of various sizes. On top of that, details on retention policies and compliance features are not completely outlined on the homepage. Pricing for Barracuda Email Archiving is not stated here, so ask the vendor for current figures. On free options: Free trial.
Drawbacks to consider: May need extra Barracuda options.
Choose Smarsh Enterprise Archive for multi-channel communications archiving. Smarsh is made for multi-channel archiving, so it might be more than needed if you only need email archiving. Its full feature set could come with higher complexity.
Where it is weaker: Pricing not transparent.
If you need a focused email archiving tool, consider alternatives. The product supports supervision and eDiscovery, making it right for financial services and other highly regulated sectors. Smarsh Enterprise Archive is a cloud-based option for capturing, archiving, and supervising electronic communications across numerous channels, including email. It is aimed at organizations in regulated industries that require to monitor and retain communications for compliance. Check the vendor site for Smarsh Enterprise Archive pricing; none is listed in this comparison. Free options: Not stated.
Mimecast Email Archiving works best for integrated email security and archiving. If you only need entry-level retention, a more straightforward tool might be more appropriate. Also, the option is cloud-based and aims to protect data whereas simplifying compliance.
Mimecast Email Archiving is part of a broader platform that comes with email security, data protection, and governance. It is made for organizations that want to consolidate archiving with other email security functions. Check the vendor site for Mimecast Email Archiving pricing; none is listed in this comparison. Free plan details: Not stated.
Downsides: Needs vendor consultation for specifics.
Proofpoint Enterprise Archive is built with intent-based protection and archiving in mind. Proofpoint Enterprise Archive is part of Proofpoint's agentic security system, which emphasizes intent-based protection for people, data, and AI. It gives you archiving as part of a broader security and compliance option.
Limits to weigh: Focus on security might overshadow pure archiving.
On top of that, if you seek a straightforward archiving tool, Proofpoint might be more than necessary. The tool is built for enterprises that require solid protection and archiving capabilities. It is especially suited for organizations with complicated compliance requirements. More specifically, the focus on AI and intent-based protection could need specialized knowledge. Pricing for Proofpoint Enterprise Archive is not stated here, so ask the vendor for current figures. Trial and free access: Not stated.
Ask each vendor, from Google Workspace Vault to Proofpoint Enterprise Archive, for a written quote; none of them publishes a starting price.
Take the trial from Barracuda Email Archiving and push a live task through it before you pay.
Before choosing Google Workspace Vault, weigh its main limit: restricted to Google Workspace.
Check whether Proofpoint Enterprise Archive bills monthly or annually, and what cancelling early costs.
The entry price of Barracuda Email Archiving is only the starting point; model the full cost with seats and extras.
How we picked
Ainotely looked at what each vendor publishes: pricing, plan limits, feature coverage for email Archiving software for compliance retention and stated drawbacks. No hands-on testing is claimed. Treat prices as a snapshot: vendors change plans often, so check the vendor site for the figure that applies today. The sequence is a judgement call: typical use case first, then pricing transparency, then free access. Use the profiles to check fit.
Every price and plan detail on this page comes from the vendors’ own websites. We did not run hands-on tests unless the text says so, and we do not publish star ratings or review scores. See how we score and our disclosure.
Keep your shortlist in one place
Paste prices, trial dates and notes from this guide into Ainotely, our AI note app. It files them into a topic and pulls out tasks like “cancel trial by Friday”. Free 7-day trial, no card needed.
Does any tool for email Archiving software for compliance retention here have a free plan?
No tool in this list, Google Workspace Vault and Proofpoint Enterprise Archive included, has a permanent free plan. Barracuda Email Archiving offer a trial. Trials and quotes are the usual route, so plan a short evaluation period.
Why is compliance retention important?
Compliance retention ensures that emails are kept for the required period to satisfy laws and regulations. Failure to retain emails can result in penalties and legal issues. Archiving software automates this process.
Do these tools publish their prices?
No. None of the tools, from Google Workspace Vault to Proofpoint Enterprise Archive, shows a fixed starting price here, so budget time for quotes.
Is Google Workspace Vault the right pick for everyone comparing email Archiving software for compliance retention?
No single tool suits every team. Google Workspace Vault comes first because it fits Archiving for Google Workspace, while Barracuda Email Archiving suits Email protection and archiving bundle and Smarsh Enterprise Archive suits multi-channel communications archiving. Match the tool to your own size, budget and workflow before deciding.
How do I choose the right archiving tool?
Consider your email product, compliance requirements, and need for multi-channel support. Evaluate features like retention policies, eDiscovery, and supervision. Also check scalability and integration with existing systems.
Can I try these tools before paying?
Often, yes. Barracuda Email Archiving offers a free trial. Use your own data and a real task during the test, and check what the free tier or trial limits before you rely on it. The 5 tool cards above repeat this per product for email Archiving software for compliance retention, with the listed price or "pricing on request".